Best roofing contractors in Bainbridge
These are the top 8 roofing contractors serving Bainbridge, ranked by our earned composite score, which weighs rating, review volume, recency, and sentiment (see our methodology). Most of the businesses here handle the full range of roofing work, from storm repair to full replacement, so this list runs as one ordered ranking rather than split by specialty.
Picks are ranked by relevance to roofing contractor.
At a glance
| # | Business | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Porter Family Water Damage | 4.9 (30) | — | Storm & water damage restoration |
| 2 | Strickland Roofing & Construction | 5 (4) | — | Insurance-backed roof replacement |
| 3 | Heritage Xteriors | 5 (1) | — | Full-service roofing & exteriors |
| 4 | New South Roofing | 3.7 (3) | — | Budget-friendly roof installs |
| 5 | Bainbridge Roofing LLC | 4.2 (5) | — | Historic metal roof repair |
| 6 | Bruce Kelley Construction | 5 (1) | — | General construction & roofing |
| 7 | Strickland's Roofing LLC | — | — | Long-tenure GAF roofing |
| 8 | Varnum Roofing | — | — | New-to-market roofing option |
1. Porter Family Water Damage
4.9 (30 reviews)
Porter Family Water Damage carries the highest composite score in this group, backed by a high-confidence base of 30 reviews averaging 4.9 stars. Customers consistently point to Troy's fast response, plain-language explanations, and direct coordination with insurance adjusters on jobs ranging from home floods to a commercial auditorium. For a roofing project that starts with storm or water damage, that combination of speed, documentation, and cleanup is hard to match on this list.
- Same-day or next-day response for water emergencies
- Troy communicates directly with insurance adjusters
- Daily moisture testing and thorough documentation for claims
- Containment work to prevent damage from spreading, plus a clean site after
Services: roof replacement
2. Strickland Roofing & Construction
5 (4 reviews)
Strickland Roofing & Construction has a perfect 5-star average, with reviewers highlighting punctual crews, fair pricing, and direct work with State Farm on insurance claims. They've also handled out-of-area jobs without losing responsiveness. The review count is still small, so treat this as a strong early track record rather than a long-established one.
- Professional, on-time crews
- Direct experience handling State Farm insurance claims
Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, commercial roofing
3. Heritage Xteriors
5 (1 reviews)
Heritage Xteriors holds a 5-star rating from a single detailed review describing exceptional service and efficient project completion. The scope covers full-service roofing and exterior work, but with only one account on file and from several years back, this is best treated as a lead worth a direct conversation rather than a proven pattern.
- Described as exceptional customer service
- High-quality, efficient project completion
Services: roof replacement, roof repair, commercial roofing, residential roofing
4. New South Roofing
3.7 (3 reviews)
New South Roofing shows a mixed record: two reviewers praised the installation crew's skill and fair pricing, while a separate account described missed callbacks and unanswered quote requests. The company covers the full range of roofing services when engaged, so it's worth a direct call to check on current responsiveness before committing.
- Skilled installation crew, per reviewers
- Reasonable, competitive pricing
Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, commercial roofing
5. Bainbridge Roofing LLC
4.2 (5 reviews)
Bainbridge Roofing LLC brings specific experience with older metal roofing, including emergency repairs after Hurricane Michael, and most reviewers describe the crew as professional and customer-focused. An older inquiry went without a callback, but the more recent feedback points to responsive emergency service, which makes this a solid pick for a historic or metal-roof project.
- Deep experience with older and historic metal roofing
- Emergency response after Hurricane Michael
Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, commercial roofing
6. Bruce Kelley Construction
5 (1 reviews)
Bruce Kelley Construction has a single 5-star review on record, which isn't enough yet to establish a reliable pattern of service. It's included here as a general construction and roofing contractor based in Bainbridge, best approached with a direct conversation about scope and timeline before booking.
- Single review on file rates the work 5 stars
- Positioned as a general construction and roofing contractor in Bainbridge
Services: roof replacement, commercial roofing, residential roofing
7. Strickland's Roofing LLC
Strickland's Roofing LLC brings over 40 years in business and 7 years as a GAF Presidents Club member, along with stated licensing and insurance. There are no Google reviews on file yet to independently verify recent customer experience, so this entry rests on tenure and manufacturer recognition rather than review volume.
- Over 40 years in business
- GAF Presidents Club member for 7 years
- Licensed and insured, per business info
- Serves Bainbridge and surrounding areas
Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, commercial roofing
8. Varnum Roofing
Varnum Roofing rounds out this list as a Bainbridge-area roofing option, though there isn't yet enough review data to describe a clear customer experience pattern. Anyone considering this contractor should ask for references directly and get a written quote to compare against the more established names here.
- Listed as a roofing contractor serving the Bainbridge area
- Worth including in a direct quote comparison alongside more established names
Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, commercial roofing