Best roofing contractors in Madison

★★★★★5 (112 reviews)

Temple Roofing posts a perfect 5-star average across 112 reviews and the highest composite score in Madison. Crews led by named techs like Joshua Wilkins, Michael, Tyler, and Brandon show up on time, often finish in a single day, and get called out repeatedly for thorough site cleanup.

• Perfect 5-star rating across 112 reviews
• Jobs often completed in one day or less
• Named technicians praised for knowledge and follow-up
• Careful site cleanup after every job

Services: roof inspection, roof replacement, gutter services, commercial roofing

★★★★★5 (63 reviews)

Ascend Roofing and Contracting holds a 5-star average across 63 reviews with high confidence in that score. Reviewers point to Kyle, Robert, and Jordan going beyond patch jobs, from emergency tarps to full replacement, with honest assessments, fair pricing, and same-day completions on many jobs.

• 5-star average with high review volume and confidence
• Strong insurance claim advocacy from named staff
• Same-day completion on many jobs
• Honest assessments over unnecessary upsells

Services: roof inspection, roof replacement, commercial roofing, roof repair

★★★★★4.9 (167 reviews)

Red Roofing & Gutters has the largest review base in the top tier at 167, with a 4.9 average. Named techs Zach, Brandon, Aaron, Andrew, and Kevin draw consistent praise for detailed photo-based inspections, and the crew handles gutters alongside roofing with fast, often same-week scheduling.

• 167 reviews at a 4.9 average, one of the largest samples in Madison
• Detailed photo-report inspections
• Fast scheduling, often same-week turnaround
• Handles gutters alongside roofing and insurance claims

Services: roof inspection, roof replacement, gutter services, commercial roofing

★★★★★4.8 (571 reviews)

Humbled Roofing carries by far the largest review base in Madison at 571, with named project managers Rafael, Christian, Bryson, Matthew, and Kaleb praised for walking homeowners through replacements step-by-step. Crews complete many replacements in a single day and have helped neighbors work through hail-damage insurance claims.

• 571 reviews, the largest sample size on this list
• Named project managers communicate step-by-step throughout the job
• One-day replacements with thorough debris cleanup
• Experience navigating insurance claims, including hail damage

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★5 (19 reviews)

Talmadge Roofing, led by Matt Siso, holds a 5-star average with daily photo updates and same-day responses to inquiries. The crew handles replacements, repairs, and inspections, guides customers through insurance claims from adjuster contact through approval, and is specifically called out for HOA and community project work.

• 5-star average with a strong sentiment score
• Daily photo updates and thorough cleanup
• Full insurance claim support from adjuster to approval
• Experience with HOA and community projects

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, roof inspection, commercial roofing

★★★★★4.5 (4 reviews)

Gary Bratcher Roofing is a one-owner operation, with Gary handling jobs directly and reviewers calling out his honesty and straightforward manner. It's a fit for homeowners who want to deal directly with the person doing the work.

• Owner handles jobs personally, start to finish
• Reviewers describe him as honest and straightforward

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, gutter services, residential roofing

★★★★★5 (2 reviews)

Dunlop Roofing & Consulting has a small but perfect review record, with Crystal and Mike named for professionalism and competitive pricing on a commercial roof replacement. It's worth a look for commercial work in particular given that pricing feedback.

• 5-star average on the reviews collected so far
• Competitive pricing noted on a commercial project

Services: roof replacement, commercial roofing, roof repair, gutter services