Best roofing contractors in Columbus

★★★★★4.9 (68 reviews)score 88/100

Supreme Service Company pairs a near-perfect 4.9 rating across 68 reviews with staff customers know by name: Jasmine and Dominic Granville show up repeatedly for their speed and clear updates during insurance and storm-damage jobs. Certifications from Tamko, Atlas, Owens Corning, and GAF back up the consistent praise for cleanup and craftsmanship, and Dominic has taken emergency calls after hours.

• Same-day response on emergency and storm calls
• Named staff (Jasmine, Dominic Granville) praised repeatedly for communication
• Certified installer for Tamko, Atlas, Owens Corning, and GAF shingles
• Thorough cleanup, including extras like facial board replacement

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, commercial roofing

★★★★★5 (50 reviews)score 88/100

Crosby Roofing holds a perfect 5.0 across 50 reviews, with Hayden personally leading inspections and crews finishing full roof installs the same day. Reviewers point to transparent pricing and a straightforward process from tearoff to walkthrough, backed by CertainTeed Select Shingle Master status and a 50-year warranty.

• Same-day roof installation
• Owner Hayden personally leads inspections
• CertainTeed Select Shingle Master certification
• 50-year warranty on installs

Services: roof inspection, roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing

★★★★★4.8 (97 reviews)score 87/100

Dave built a 4.8 rating over 97 reviews by walking customers through insurance claims personally and finishing full replacements in a single day, often throwing in pressure-washing or gutter painting at no charge. Nearly all recent feedback is strongly positive, from 19 recent five-star reviews praising speed and communication.

• Owner Dave manages projects from estimate to completion
• One-day completion on full roof replacements
• Guides customers through insurance adjuster communication
• Extras like pressure-washing and gutter painting included at no charge

Watch out: One reviewer described a slow response getting a warranty leak resolved after an otherwise smooth replacement.

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, roof inspection

★★★★★4.9 (53 reviews)score 87/100

Gary Kent has run this outfit for 37 years and still shows up on jobs himself, which shows in 27 straight five-star reviews and a 4.9 average over 53 reviews. Customers repeatedly mention same-day or next-day turnarounds, transparent quotes, and a yard left cleaner than it started, with no complaints turning up in the review record.

• 37 years in business, owner works alongside the crew
• Same-day or next-day service common
• Handles insurance claims and documentation directly
• Transparent, fair-value estimates

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, roof inspection

★★★★★4.9 (54 reviews)score 87/100

Frank Savage's crew turns around full replacements and commercial jobs in one to two days, even in rough weather, and reviewers credit his direct communication style, complete with photo updates and plain-language explanations. A 4.9 average across 54 reviews reflects consistent praise for competitive pricing and careful cleanup.

• Jobs completed in one to two days
• Owner Frank Savage communicates directly with photo updates
• Detailed, itemized quotes
• Protective measures taken for landscaping during work

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, roof inspection

★★★★★4.9 (120 reviews)score 86/100

Roofing World has the largest review base on this list at 120, holding a 4.9 average with named foremen like Ernest, Pierce, Allen, and Lonnie praised for punctual 7am starts and careful work on tricky rooflines. Crews send progress photos and use proper ventilation and fire-rated materials, though sentiment here trails others on this list due to some pushback on sales-call tactics.

• One-day roof replacements
• Named foremen known for professionalism (Ernest, Pierce, Allen)
• Progress photos sent during installation
• Proper ventilation and fire-rated materials used

Watch out: Some reviewers mention persistent marketing calls, and one job had debris left behind that the company offered to correct.

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, commercial roofing

★★★★★5 (25 reviews)score 84/100

Every one of Matter-of-Fact Roofing's 25 reviews is five stars, with Scott and Silas singled out for patience and straight talk during insurance claims. Inspections here have caught damage other contractors missed, and customers describe leaks staying fixed and yards left spotless. The review count is on the smaller side, but the pattern is entirely positive.

• Insurance claim navigation and negotiation
• Named crew (Scott, Silas) known for honesty
• Same-day or next-day emergency leak response
• Thorough yard protection and cleanup

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, roof inspection

★★★★★5 (19 reviews)score 83/100

Matthew runs Baseline Coatings hands-on, and reviewers keep coming back to one theme: he solves leaks that previous contractors couldn't. A 5.0 average across 19 reviews points to fair pricing, punctuality, and clear communication, though the review base is still relatively small.

• Owner Matthew personally handles jobs
• Track record fixing chronic leaks others missed
• Fair, honest pricing
• Fast turnaround and clean site after work

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, commercial roofing

★★★★★5 (18 reviews)score 82/100

Simply Roofing's 18 reviews are all five stars, with customers noting that repaired sections blend in so well you can't tell where the patch is. Several reviewers say the team diagnosed root causes that other roofers had missed, catching problems before they got worse. It's a smaller sample size than some competitors, but the feedback is consistently detailed and positive.

• All five-star reviews across 18 ratings
• Materials matched closely for seamless repairs
• Diagnoses root causes rather than just symptoms
• Quick response to leaks and emergencies

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, commercial roofing, residential roofing

★★★★★4.6 (88 reviews)score 82/100

Liberty Roofing Professionals typically wraps a full roof in a single day, with technicians like Josh, Mitch Deering, and Que earning trust for honesty about scope and timeline. An 88-review base backs up the pattern, and financing options add flexibility for bigger jobs, though a handful of reviewers mention a recurring leak or unwanted repeat sales calls.

• One-day roof completion typical
• Named technicians (Josh, Mitch Deering) trusted across reviews
• Financing available
• Same-day emergency repairs offered

Watch out: A few reviewers reported a leak that persisted after repair, and some mention repeat estimate calls after declining.

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, roof inspection

★★★★★4.6 (66 reviews)score 81/100

This father-and-sons operation, Danny, Shane, and Brandon, gets credit for declining jobs when a roof doesn't actually need replacing, plus magnetic nail sweeps that leave yards debris-free. The 4.6 average across 66 reviews includes two older complaints about scheduling and billing, but the recent pattern reviewers describe is strongly positive.

• Father-and-sons crew known by name
• Magnetic debris sweeps and tarp setup during removal
• Honest inspections, will decline unnecessary work
• Same-day or next-day completion on replacements

Watch out: A couple of older reviews cite missed appointments and a billing dispute, though recent feedback trends positive.

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, roof inspection

★★★★★5 (21 reviews)score 81/100

Freddie Diaz oversees every project personally, and One Stop Roofing's 21 reviews are unanimous five stars for fast scheduling and cleanup that leaves no debris behind. Reviewers consistently mention transparent pricing with no upselling, though the review count and recency here are modest compared with the top of this list.

• Owner Freddie Diaz personally oversees projects
• Same-day or next-day turnaround common
• Honest advice with no upselling
• Guaranteed thorough site cleanup

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, roof inspection

★★★★★5 (12 reviews)score 80/100

Summit Roofing Professionals has a short but perfect record: all 12 reviews are five stars, with Davis and Jessie named for managing jobs efficiently and answering questions fast. Reviewers cover replacements, repairs, and gutter installs, praising property protection and follow-through, though 12 reviews is a smaller sample than most others on this list.

• Named staff (Davis, Jessie, Dale) known by customers
• Meticulous property protection and cleanup
• Responsive communication with homeowners and insurers
• Handles replacements, repairs, and gutters

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, roof inspection

★★★★☆4.4 (148 reviews)score 80/100

Alan Townsend has the second-largest review count on this list at 148, built over 40 years of matching shingles by eye and catching leaks other roofers miss. Most reviewers describe fair pricing and quick arrival, often getting estimates the next morning, though one complaint alleges incomplete flashing and vent work from three years ago that needed a follow-up repair elsewhere.

• Responds same day or next morning
• Finds leaks other roofers miss
• Fair pricing, no upcharging reported
• 40+ years matching shingles by eye

Watch out: One older complaint alleges incomplete flashing and vent work that required repairs elsewhere.

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, roof inspection

★★★★☆4.2 (72 reviews)score 79/100

Columbus Seamless covers more ground than roofing alone, including gutters, siding, windows, and doors, with Steve Jenkins consulting on estimates and crew members JP, Nick, Kevin, and Christina named often for courtesy and speed. Reviewers say Steve catches problems other companies missed, like misaligned gutters, and the business has served repeat customers since 2023 with no substantive complaints in the review set.

• Owner Steve Jenkins personally consults on each estimate
• Proactive problem-catching on past jobs, with warranty follow-up
• Crews trained to leave yards spotless
• Covers roofing, gutters, siding, and windows in one shop

Services: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, commercial roofing