Georgia Roofing Contractor Guide
Menu
Free roof estimate

A1roofman

Updated 2026-08-18 · 12,350 reviewed · 600 listed · Scored from 23 Google reviews · How we rank ›

3.3(23) 41 low data composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified
Roof ReplacementRoof RepairGutter Installation & RepairResidential Roofing
A1roofman
Services
Roof Replacement, Roof Repair, Gutter Installation & Repair
Reviews
23

What recent reviews say

A1roofman delivers quick, polished work on good days but earns most of its low rating (3.3/5) from broken warranties, no-shows on follow-up calls, and pricing that shifts sharply between quote and site visit. Older five-star reviews praise Jay Diamond's hands-on style and crew professionalism; recent one and two-star reviews detail leaks within months, abandoned elderly homeowners, and warranty refusals.

Based on limited recent reviews, so treat this as low-confidence.

Praised for
  • professional crew
  • timely completion
  • quality work on well-executed jobs
  • responsive during estimation
Watch-outs
  • does not honor warranty claims
  • poor follow-up and missed appointments
  • inconsistent estimates and price padding
  • materials underperform
shoddy-workmanshipleak-recurredmissed-deadlinespoor-communicationdelayed-responseoverpriced
Think twice if: Warranty follow-up and leak repairs are unreliable; multiple reviewers report unresponded calls after roof failure.

Strengths

  • quick single-day job completion
  • available for insurance claims work
  • owner Jay Diamond personally involved in estimates

Worth knowing

  • Owner Jay Diamond personally handles estimates
  • Advertises 5-year workmanship and 20-year material warranties but does not honor them consistently
  • Estimates often rise $1,000+ after crew inspection
  • Crew works at speed (roofs completed in one or two days)
  • Does not appear at job sites for warranty work

What reviews say by service

Roof Replacement
Finished quickly and looked good initially; multiple roofs leaked within months despite warranty claims.
Roof Repair
Leaks recurred after repair; owner did not answer calls to fulfill warranty.
Gutter Installation & Repair
Gutters removed or installed as part of jobs; no specific praise or complaint.
Residential Roofing
Fast turnaround on install praised; leak recurrence and warranty refusal are the recurring problem.

How it compares

  • Rated 3.3 against a 4.69 average across the 320 gutter installation & repair businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 59% of the businesses in this directory.

How we scored this

How We Score
Star rating 34
Review volume 60
Review recency 0
Review sentiment 43
Profile completeness 50
Verification 0

Rating breakdown

5
12
4
1
3
0
2
2
1
8

Common questions

Does A1roofman offer a warranty?
Advertises 5-year workmanship and 20-year material warranties, but multiple reviews report the owner did not honor these after leaks or damage appeared.
How long does a roof job take?
Most jobs are completed in one or two days according to reviews.
Will Jay Diamond meet with me in person?
He handles estimates personally, but after the contract is signed, the crew does the work and the owner may not be present at the site.
Request a quote

Similar roofing contractor nearby

Anchor Roofing
62

Anchor Roofing

4.1(26)✓ Google-verified

Joey Knight's crew typically delivers work on schedule, cleans up well, and prices fairly, earning 69% five-star reviews. However, a meaningful minority report unresolved leaks, ignored warranty callbacks, and poor follow-up. Most recent positive reviews praise reliability and reasonable costs, but older cases show patterns of slow response when problems emerge months after installation.

Roof ReplacementRoof RepairMetal Roofing
View profile
Alfred Roofing & Remodeling
22 low data

Alfred Roofing & Remodeling

No rating yet✓ Google-verified

Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.

Roof ReplacementResidential Roofing
View profile
United Roofing
60 low data

United Roofing

5.0(2)✓ Google-verified

Two five-star reviews highlight United Roofing's speed and quality. A crew completed a 93-square roof in two days while maintaining standards under owner Moises's oversight. One reviewer called them the best roofing company in Columbus.

Roof ReplacementRoof Inspection & Insurance ClaimsCommercial Roofing
View profile

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-08-18