Firebrand Roofing vs Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters: which for gutter installation & repair?
Both Firebrand Roofing and Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters are genuine alternatives for gutter work in Georgia, but they lean different ways once you get past the star ratings. This comparison, built on our methodology, weighs what actually matters for gutter installation and repair: specialization, storm-damage turnaround, and what happens after the crew leaves.
The differences that matter
- Gutter specialization. Crosby's own name includes "Seamless Gutters" and its review summary calls out drone roof surveys and storm turnaround, while Firebrand's praise and pros center almost entirely on roof repair, replacement, and inspection rather than gutter-specific work.
- Insurance claim handling. Firebrand manages insurance claims end-to-end and will tell a customer when a claim isn't worth filing, which matters if gutter damage is being bundled into a larger storm claim.
- Post-job follow-up. Crosby's summary specifically notes crews returning after storms to fix minor issues at no charge and warranty follow-up that's actually honored, a useful signal for gutters, which are prone to post-storm loosening and minor leaks.
- Turnaround speed. Crosby has a documented fast turnaround (a roof reshingled in two days after a tree fall), suggesting a crew built for quick storm-response jobs, the kind that often includes gutter replacement alongside roof work.
- Review volume and score. Firebrand holds a perfect 5.0 from 253 reviews with a composite score of 94.4, while Crosby sits at 4.8 from 322 reviews with a composite score of 91, both rated high confidence.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Firebrand Roofing: 5 (253 reviews)
- Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters: 4.8 (322 reviews)
- Services
- Firebrand Roofing: roof replacement, metal roofing, roof inspection, gutter services
- Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters: roof replacement, roof repair, roof inspection, commercial roofing
- Named specialty
- Firebrand Roofing: Roof repair, replacement, and inspection with insurance-claim coordination
- Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters: Seamless gutters named in the business itself, plus drone-aided roof and storm-damage assessment
- Best for storm-related gutter damage
- Firebrand Roofing: Strong if the job is tied to a larger insurance claim needing an advocate
- Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters: Strong if you want fast turnaround and a crew that circles back after the storm at no charge
- Verification
- Firebrand Roofing: Google-verified
- Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Firebrand Roofing: 94
- Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters: 91
What reviewers say
Firebrand Roofing
Firebrand's 253 five-star reviews center on Boaz Clark and his team handling roof repairs, replacements, and inspections with personal attention and speed. Customers consistently praise Bobby, Nick, and Boaz by name for showing up the same day, walking them through options (including financing), managing insurance claims end-to-end, and cleaning up meticulously after the job.
What sets them apart is the willingness to say "no" when an insurance claim isn't worth the deductible, and the little extras like blowing debris from roof valleys or providing video inspection records. Multiple customers chose Firebrand specifically to avoid transient "white van" crews, and reviewers note that Boaz and his team deliver on their promises and communicate at every step.
Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters
Lee Martin and the Crosby team earn repeated trust by answering phones, delivering on time, and pricing fairly. Crews arrive early to beat Georgia heat, work cleanly around pools and landscaping, and follow up after storms to fix minor issues at no charge. Reviewers value the lack of surprises: estimates are detailed, staff explain each step, and site cleanup is thorough before they leave.
Multiple homeowners and a realtor rehire them across properties. Specific strengths include storm damage turnover (a roof reshingled in two days after a tree fall), drone roof surveys that catch problems home inspectors miss, and warranty follow-up that is genuinely honored. Named crew members (Lee, David, Chris, Randy, Junior, Cailey) appear consistently in praise for responsiveness and knowing their trade.
Which should you pick?
Pick Firebrand Roofing if
- You need someone to manage an insurance claim from filing to payout, including telling you when it's not worth pursuing
- You want the owner or senior techs (Boaz, Bobby, Nick) personally on site rather than a rotating crew
- The gutter work is part of a bigger roof repair or replacement job
Pick Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters if
- The job is gutters specifically, seamless gutters is literally their trade
- You want documented fast turnaround after storm damage and a crew that comes back to fix small issues free of charge
- You want a drone survey to catch problems before they become a bigger repair
Verdict
This comes down to fit, not the score gap. If the gutter job is standalone or storm-driven and you want speed plus a no-cost follow-up visit, Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters is built for exactly that, gutters are in its name for a reason. If the gutter damage is tangled up with a roof insurance claim and you want one team steering the whole process, including telling you honestly when a claim isn't worth filing, Firebrand Roofing is the safer pick despite being the roof-first specialist of the two.
Having trouble picking the right contractor?
Describe your project and compare quotes from suitable roofing contractor in Georgia.
We may pass your enquiry to partner providers who can do the work and earn a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published method, not on referral fees.
FAQ
- Which company is more specialized in gutters specifically?
- Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters has gutter work built into its name and business identity, while Firebrand's review summary and praise focus on roof repair, replacement, and inspection.
- Which is better if my gutter damage is part of an insurance claim?
- Firebrand is noted for managing insurance claims end-to-end and will advise against filing if it's not worth the deductible, which is useful when gutter damage is rolled into a roof claim.
- Which one follows up after the job is done?
- Crosby's reviews specifically mention crews returning after storms to fix minor issues at no charge and warranties that are genuinely honored.
- Which has the higher rating?
- Firebrand Roofing has a 5.0 rating from 253 reviews and a composite score of 94.4, while Crosby has a 4.8 rating from 322 reviews and a composite score of 91.