Roofing Done Wright vs Black Dog Roofing: which one for a roof repair?
Roofing Done Wright and Black Dog Roofing are both genuine options for roof repair in Georgia, and both post strong, high-confidence records. The real question for a repair job is narrower than the overall score: who handles your specific situation, whether that's a straightforward leak fix or a storm claim, and who's upfront about what it'll cost. Our methodology weighs that fit alongside the raw ratings.
The differences that matter
- Insurance claim handling. Roofing Done Wright keeps a public adjuster on staff to work insurance claims directly, while Black Dog Roofing coordinates with outside adjusters and walks homeowners through material samples.
- Pricing transparency. Roofing Done Wright is called out repeatedly for honest repair-versus-replace calls and quotes that undercut competitors, whereas Black Dog Roofing's reviews don't mention pricing at all.
- Storm damage focus. Black Dog Roofing's reviews center on storm damage repair with drone inspections and adjuster coordination, while Roofing Done Wright's repair work reads as general-purpose rather than storm-specific.
- Turnaround style. Roofing Done Wright documents jobs with photos and daily updates over a same-day-to-multi-day window, while Black Dog Roofing leans toward finishing repairs in a single day, sometimes before noon.
- Track record depth. Roofing Done Wright has a larger review base (487 vs. 291) and a slightly higher composite score, though both sit in the same top tier.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Roofing Done Wright: 5 (487 reviews)
- Black Dog Roofing: 5 (291 reviews)
- Services
- Roofing Done Wright: roof replacement, roof repair, roof inspection, commercial roofing
- Black Dog Roofing: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, roof inspection
- Insurance claim support
- Roofing Done Wright: In-house public adjuster works the claim directly
- Black Dog Roofing: Coordinates with adjusters, presents material samples
- Storm damage specialty
- Roofing Done Wright: Not called out as a specialty in reviews
- Black Dog Roofing: Named as their bread-and-butter, with free drone inspections
- Repair pricing honesty
- Roofing Done Wright: Frequently praised for quotes below competitors
- Black Dog Roofing: No pricing mentioned in reviews
- Verification
- Roofing Done Wright: Google-verified
- Black Dog Roofing: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Roofing Done Wright: 94
- Black Dog Roofing: 94
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Roofing Done Wright
Roofing Done Wright handles replacements, repairs, and inspections with named staff who walk homeowners through each step, often helping file insurance claims. Work typically finishes the same day or within days, crews clean up thoroughly, and the business stands out for refusing unnecessary upsells and delivering honest estimates that often cost less than competitors quoted.
Kyle Kerns, Matt Hopkins, Christina, Andrew, Aaron Bramlett, and Robert Hamilton appear frequently in reviews as knowledgeable points of contact. Customers praise photo documentation, daily communication, and crew efficiency. Insurance agents and HOA contacts recommend them repeatedly.
Black Dog Roofing
Black Dog Roofing delivers consistent results across roof replacement and repair. The operation hinges on staff who handle insurance paperwork, answer questions without pressure, and dispatch crews that finish jobs in a single day, leaving properties spotless. Named team members-Kurtis, Cody Hill, Daniel Luzzi, Ross Davis, Greg Hickman, Rhett Smith, and others-appear repeatedly in reviews, signaling stability and continuity.
Storm damage is their bread and butter: they inspect, coordinate with adjusters, present material samples, and execute replacements before noon when possible. A drone inspection service is mentioned. Repairs run the same track. No pricing is stated in reviews, and no complaints surface across 18 recent reviews graded 5 stars.
Which should you pick?
Pick Roofing Done Wright if
- You want a dedicated public adjuster handling your insurance paperwork start to finish
- You want a clear repair-vs-replace opinion and a quote you can compare against other bids
- You value daily photo updates and communication while the crew works
Pick Black Dog Roofing if
- Your repair is tied to storm damage and you want a drone inspection before anyone climbs up
- You want adjusters and material samples walked through on-site as part of the claim process
- You're fine with a same-day repair crew and a slightly smaller but spotless review record
Verdict
This comes down to what kind of repair you're dealing with, not which score is higher. If the damage traces back to a storm and you'll be filing a claim, Black Dog Roofing's drone inspections and adjuster walkthroughs are built for exactly that. If it's a more everyday leak or repair and you want a business that tells you plainly whether you even need a full fix, plus an in-house adjuster and pricing that reviewers say beats competing quotes, Roofing Done Wright fits better.
Having trouble picking the right contractor?
Describe your project and compare quotes from suitable roofing contractor in Georgia.
We may pass your enquiry to partner providers who can do the work and earn a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published method, not on referral fees.
FAQ
- Which is better for a storm-damage roof repair?
- Black Dog Roofing, since storm damage is described as its main focus, including drone inspections and adjuster coordination for claims.
- Which one is more transparent about repair costs?
- Roofing Done Wright, whose reviews repeatedly mention honest repair-vs-replace advice and pricing that came in below competing quotes. Black Dog Roofing's reviews don't discuss pricing.
- Does either company have an in-house insurance adjuster?
- Roofing Done Wright keeps a public adjuster on staff. Black Dog Roofing works with outside adjusters rather than an in-house one.
- Which company has more reviews?
- Roofing Done Wright has 487 Google reviews at a 5.0 rating, compared to Black Dog Roofing's 291 reviews, also at 5.0.