Roofing Done Wright vs Eastside Roofing: which fits your residential roof job?
Roofing Done Wright and Eastside Roofing, LLC are both strong candidates for a residential roof replacement or repair in Georgia, and both score in the mid-90s under our methodology. The real choice comes down to how each handles your insurance claim, what backs the work once it's on your roof, and which crew's process fits how hands-on you want to be.
The differences that matter
- Insurance claim handling. Roofing Done Wright keeps a public adjuster on staff to fight your claim directly, while Eastside leans on named carrier partnerships with State Farm and Amica to smooth the process.
- Proven storm performance. Eastside's reviewers point to roofs it installed years ago that held up through tornadoes, a track record Roofing Done Wright's summary doesn't mention.
- Review volume and track record. Roofing Done Wright has nearly triple the reviews (487 vs. 168), giving buyers more data points on consistency across a larger number of jobs.
- Scope beyond the roof. Eastside also does gutters and acrylic coatings across Northeast Georgia, while Roofing Done Wright's reputation centers tightly on honest replacement, repair, and inspection calls without upsells.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Roofing Done Wright: 5 (487 reviews)
- Eastside Roofing, LLC: 5 (168 reviews)
- Services
- Roofing Done Wright: roof replacement, roof repair, roof inspection, commercial roofing
- Eastside Roofing, LLC: roof replacement, roof repair, metal roofing, roof inspection
- Insurance approach
- Roofing Done Wright: In-house public adjuster helps file and fight claims
- Eastside Roofing, LLC: Direct partnerships with State Farm and Amica
- Specialties
- Roofing Done Wright: Replacements, repairs, inspections, repair-vs-replace honesty
- Eastside Roofing, LLC: Re-roofs, repairs, gutters, acrylic coatings, storm resilience
- Service footprint
- Roofing Done Wright: Not specified beyond general service area
- Eastside Roofing, LLC: Northeast Georgia
- Named team you'll likely meet
- Roofing Done Wright: Kyle Kerns, Matt Hopkins, Christina, Andrew, Aaron Bramlett, Robert Hamilton
- Eastside Roofing, LLC: Logan Smith, Zach, Danny Mojica, Will
- Verification
- Roofing Done Wright: Google-verified
- Eastside Roofing, LLC: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Roofing Done Wright: 94
- Eastside Roofing, LLC: 93
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Roofing Done Wright
Roofing Done Wright handles replacements, repairs, and inspections with named staff who walk homeowners through each step, often helping file insurance claims. Work typically finishes the same day or within days, crews clean up thoroughly, and the business stands out for refusing unnecessary upsells and delivering honest estimates that often cost less than competitors quoted.
Kyle Kerns, Matt Hopkins, Christina, Andrew, Aaron Bramlett, and Robert Hamilton appear frequently in reviews as knowledgeable points of contact. Customers praise photo documentation, daily communication, and crew efficiency. Insurance agents and HOA contacts recommend them repeatedly.
Eastside Roofing, LLC
Reviewers consistently report seamless experiences from estimate through project completion. Logan Smith stands out for detailed inspections, patient explanations, and hands-on project management. The crew finishes work in one day with meticulous cleanup, manages insurance claims without hassle, and names like Zach, Danny Mojica, and Will appear multiple times as dependable, knowledgeable technicians who respond quickly and go beyond expectations.
Their website lists state partnerships with State Farm and Amica, service across Northeast Georgia, and specialties in residential and commercial re-roofs, repairs, gutters, and acrylic coatings. Reviewers prize the warranty coverage and the fact that even multi-year-old roofs installed by Eastside have weathered tornadoes without problems.
Which should you pick?
Pick Roofing Done Wright if
- You want a public adjuster on your side for the insurance claim, not just a contractor that cooperates with your carrier
- You want a straight answer on repair vs. replace from a crew known for skipping unnecessary upsells
- You value a larger sample of reviews backing up consistency across hundreds of jobs
Pick Eastside Roofing, LLC if
- You want gutters or acrylic coatings bundled with the roof work instead of hiring a second contractor
- You're weighing warranty confidence and want a contractor with roofs that have already survived tornadoes
- You're in Northeast Georgia and want a crew with State Farm or Amica claim experience specifically
Verdict
This isn't close on score, so pick on fit. If you want someone fighting your insurer on your behalf and a blunt opinion on whether your roof even needs replacing, Roofing Done Wright is built for that. If you want a roof backed by a multi-year track record against real storms and the option to bolt on gutters or coatings in the same job, Eastside Roofing, LLC is the better match.
Having trouble picking the right contractor?
Describe your project and compare quotes from suitable roofing contractor in Georgia.
We may pass your enquiry to partner providers who can do the work and earn a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published method, not on referral fees.
FAQ
- Which company has more residential roofing reviews?
- Roofing Done Wright has 487 Google reviews versus Eastside Roofing's 168, both at a 5-star average.
- Which one is better for an insurance claim?
- Roofing Done Wright keeps a public adjuster on staff to handle claims directly, while Eastside Roofing relies on established partnerships with State Farm and Amica.
- Does either company offer more than roofing?
- Eastside Roofing also handles gutters and acrylic coatings across Northeast Georgia; Roofing Done Wright's reviews focus on roof replacement, repair, and inspection work.
- Which has a stronger track record against storm damage?
- Eastside Roofing's reviews specifically mention older installs that survived tornadoes, a point not raised in Roofing Done Wright's review summary.