Roofing Done Wright vs Firebrand Roofing: which one for a roof replacement?
Both Roofing Done Wright and Firebrand Roofing show up as strong, genuine alternatives for a roof replacement in Georgia, each with a perfect 5-star average and reviewers who trust their assessments over a hard sell. Following our methodology, this comparison focuses on what actually changes the outcome of a replacement job: who handles your insurance claim, who shows up on site, and how the work gets documented.
The differences that matter
- Insurance claim handling. Roofing Done Wright keeps a public adjuster on staff to work the claim directly, while Firebrand's team (Boaz, Bobby, Nick) manages the claim end-to-end but will also tell a homeowner outright when filing isn't worth the deductible.
- Owner vs. team presence. Firebrand's reviews center on owner Boaz Clark showing up in person for inspections and the job itself, while Roofing Done Wright spreads the work across a named bench of staff (Kyle Kerns, Matt Hopkins, Christina, Andrew, Aaron Bramlett, Robert Hamilton).
- Documentation style. Roofing Done Wright leans on photo documentation and daily progress updates during the replacement, while Firebrand adds video inspection records and small extras like blowing debris out of roof valleys.
- Track record size. Roofing Done Wright has nearly double the review volume (487 vs. 253), giving it a longer public track record on replacements even though both hold a 5.0 average.
- Financing conversation. Firebrand's reviews specifically mention walking customers through financing options up front, which isn't called out in Roofing Done Wright's feedback.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Roofing Done Wright: 5 (487 reviews)
- Firebrand Roofing: 5 (253 reviews)
- Services
- Roofing Done Wright: roof replacement, roof repair, roof inspection, commercial roofing
- Firebrand Roofing: roof replacement, metal roofing, roof inspection, gutter services
- Best for
- Roofing Done Wright: Homeowners who want an in-house public adjuster fighting the insurance claim for them
- Firebrand Roofing: Homeowners who want the owner personally present from inspection through completion
- Standout extra
- Roofing Done Wright: Photo-documented daily cleanup and fast same-day-to-multi-day turnaround
- Firebrand Roofing: Video roof inspection records and valley debris clearing
- Verification
- Roofing Done Wright: Google-verified
- Firebrand Roofing: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Roofing Done Wright: 94
- Firebrand Roofing: 94
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Roofing Done Wright
Roofing Done Wright handles replacements, repairs, and inspections with named staff who walk homeowners through each step, often helping file insurance claims. Work typically finishes the same day or within days, crews clean up thoroughly, and the business stands out for refusing unnecessary upsells and delivering honest estimates that often cost less than competitors quoted.
Kyle Kerns, Matt Hopkins, Christina, Andrew, Aaron Bramlett, and Robert Hamilton appear frequently in reviews as knowledgeable points of contact. Customers praise photo documentation, daily communication, and crew efficiency. Insurance agents and HOA contacts recommend them repeatedly.
Firebrand Roofing
Firebrand's 253 five-star reviews center on Boaz Clark and his team handling roof repairs, replacements, and inspections with personal attention and speed. Customers consistently praise Bobby, Nick, and Boaz by name for showing up the same day, walking them through options (including financing), managing insurance claims end-to-end, and cleaning up meticulously after the job.
What sets them apart is the willingness to say "no" when an insurance claim isn't worth the deductible, and the little extras like blowing debris from roof valleys or providing video inspection records. Multiple customers chose Firebrand specifically to avoid transient "white van" crews, and reviewers note that Boaz and his team deliver on their promises and communicate at every step.
Which should you pick?
Pick Roofing Done Wright if
- You want a public adjuster on staff to handle a complicated insurance claim directly
- You value a large, established track record with 487 five-star reviews on replacements
- You want daily photo updates and a crew known for finishing fast with thorough cleanup
Pick Firebrand Roofing if
- You want the owner, Boaz Clark, personally involved in the inspection and the job
- You want financing options laid out clearly before committing to a replacement
- You like the idea of video inspection records and extra touches like valley debris removal, and want to avoid transient crews
Verdict
The real decision here isn't the score, both sit at 94.4 with identical 5.0 ratings, it's who you want managing the process. If your replacement hinges on a messy insurance claim, Roofing Done Wright's in-house public adjuster is the more direct path. If you'd rather have the owner on your roof and want extras like video inspection records and financing options spelled out up front, Firebrand Roofing fits that job better.
Having trouble picking the right contractor?
Describe your project and compare quotes from suitable roofing contractor in Georgia.
We may pass your enquiry to partner providers who can do the work and earn a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published method, not on referral fees.
FAQ
- Which company has more reviews?
- Roofing Done Wright has 487 five-star reviews compared to Firebrand Roofing's 253, though both hold a perfect 5.0 average.
- Which one helps more with insurance claims?
- Roofing Done Wright keeps a public adjuster on staff to handle claims directly. Firebrand manages claims from start to finish and will advise against filing if it isn't worth the deductible.
- Does either company offer financing?
- Firebrand Roofing's reviews specifically mention walking customers through financing options; this isn't mentioned in Roofing Done Wright's feedback.
- Who is more likely to have the owner on site?
- Firebrand Roofing's reviews center heavily on owner Boaz Clark being personally present for inspections and jobs, while Roofing Done Wright relies on a team of named staff.